

Drew Brees, Super Bowl XLIV: Brees (122 TDs against 55 INTs in four years with Sean Payton) denied Manning his second championship and wins his one and only crown. Brett Favre, Super Bowl XXXII: Elway was the sentimental favorite after three previous Super Bowl defeats and denied Favre a repeat. Dan Marino: Super Bowl XIX: Marino was the first QB to throw for over 5,000 yards in only his second season, but Montana (3 TDs) out-dueled him for his second Super Bowl crown. Roger Staubach I, Super Bowl X: Bradshaw (2 TDs) had won Super Bowl IX and Captain America (3 INTs) was left stuck on his Super Bowl VI triumph. Eli Manning II, Super Bowl XLVI: Another clutch last-minute drive and another Super Bowl MVP for Lil’ Brother to deny Brady his fourth championship. John Elway, Super Bowl XXIV: Joe Cool (5 TDs) tied Bradshaw with his fourth Super Bowl crown while Elway (18 TDs, 18 INTs in regular season) fell to 0-3 with two interceptions and a fumble. Roger Staubach II, Super Bowl XIII: Bradshaw (4 TDs) captured his third Lombardi Trophy with a 35-31 win that kept Captain America (3 TDs) from winning his third. Patrick Mahomes, Super Bowl LV: Getcha popcorn ready. The list of 1-55 is based more on what the quarterbacks had accomplished at the time they met:

1 on Serby’s Super Bowl quarterback matchup rankings. We have witnessed LIV Super Bowl quarterback matchups where one of them was the best in the league.īut never has the best in the league faced a GOAT, much less a 43-year-old GOAT, with six rings, still playing at an elite level.Īfter first giving the nod to the Joe Montana-John Elway battle, now Tom Brady vs. Girlfriend reflects on Bucs’ Super Bowl win in Rob Gronkowski tributeĪntonio Brown heads back to Florida home after wild Buccaneers exit The one thing Rams star ‘despises’ about Super Bowl celebrations The 10 best Super Bowl national anthem performances of all time
